Thursday, 11 April 2019


Sun Pharma`s senior executives wife settles Insider Trading case with SEBI

  • Abhay Arvind Gandhi (who was during the period under review CEO of Sun Pharma Laboratories Ltd a WOS of Sun Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd) and his wife traded in Ranbaxy shares soon after Japanese major Daiichi in 2014 agreed to sell Ranbaxy to Sun Pharma.
  • The proposed deal was Unpublished Price Sensitive Information (UPSI) from Feb 14, 2014 to 6th April, 2014.
  • By trading in shares of Ranbaxy during the UPSI period both violated PIT norms. 
  • The settlement amount of Rs 35.06 lakh each was approved by a panel of SEBI's Whole Time Members.
  • The trend that we can see from Settlement Orders and Adjudication Orders passed by SEBI with respect to Prohibition of Insider Trading , is that whenever there is takeover or potential takeover transactions, SEBI has gone in detail about transactions done by key people in  the respective Companies.
  • Under amended PIT regulations (effective from 1 April 2019), every listed Company has to maintain digital database whenever UPSI is shared. And conduct enquiry about any leak or suspected leak of UPSI. 
  • Had this incident taken place after 1 April 2019, SUN Pharma would have required to conduct an internal inquiry about suspected leak of UPSI and submit a report to SEBI.




  
In the matter of Shri Balaji Cycles Private Limited (1st Appellant) and Shri Suresh Kumar Sharma (2nd Appellant) Versus The Registrar of Companies (Respondent)
  • Applicant Company was incorporated on 30.04.1997
  • The Company failed to file statutory documents viz. Annual Return and Balance Sheet as per section159/220 of the Companies Act,1956.
  • The Company was struck off by the Registrar of Companies (hereinafter referred to as ROC) vide official Gazette Notification dated 23.06.2007.
  • The applicant filed the application with National Company Law Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as NCLT) for restoration of company after almost a decade.
  • ROC objected the restoration on the following grounds:
  • Company to provide strict proof showing that the company is carrying on business since inception by providing proof such as submitting of income tax returns, viability of running the company, composition of Board of Directors, shareholders, creditors and their consents thereof for the present application for restoration.
  • The applicant replied that the company did not receive any show cause notice from ROC for strike off and property adjacent to the appellant has somehow colluded with the postman to prevent any correspondence from reaching the applicant and applicant only came to know about the name of the appellant being struck off only in 2017 and various other reasons such as illness of the directors, paucity of funds etc.
  • Despite providing opportunity, the company failed to provide Income Tax Returns and placed on record the true copy of the audited Balance Sheet and Profit & loss Account only for the financial year ending on 31.03.2016.
  • Drawing adverse inference – NCLT dismissed the application.
  • Aggrieved by the order of NCLT, Applicants filed the application for restoration of company with the Appellant Tribunal.
  • During the pendency of application, the company paid the lease rentals to HSID and the same was provided as an additional proof for restoration.
  • Appellate Tribunal quashing the applicant reply stated that though the consent of shareholders and creditors is received, the same cannot be considered for this case as they are family members. Further the lease rentals have been deposited only after when the NCLT asked for proof and hence the same cannot be taken a good ground to assert that the company has already been in business or in operation.
  • NCLAT also dismissed the application as the appeal has no merits.


Wednesday, 10 April 2019

New Initiatives: Investor Complaint E-form

In our earlier newsletter dated 5th December 2018, we had discussed about Serious Complaint Form (SCP) which dealt with reporting of serious complaints against a company by filing it on MCA

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) has now introduced e-form ICP (Investor complaint eForm).http://www.mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/companyformsdownload.html 

The form was introduced for reporting complaint related to shares, debentures, bonds, fixed deposits, etc. against a company/LLP by filing it on MCA. This is an additional facility to lodge compliant other than handing over a written complaint directly to MCA official in the office of Registrar of Companies.

However, complaints related to complaint/grievances of Non-Banking Finance Company (NBFC), Residuary Non-Banking Company (RNBC) registered with RBI have to be filed with RBI.

Listed companies and also the companies which intend to get their securities listed on any recognized stock exchange can file their complaints related to issue and transfer of securities and non-payment of dividend with SEBI. Other complaints can be filed with MCA.

Chit fund companies and real estate companies can file their complaints with the concerned regulatory authority

Who can file a complaint?
  • Shareholder
  •  Investor
  • Creditor
  • Employee (It is unclear why ‘employee’ category is appearing in this form)
  •  Deposit holders
  •  Others (who do not belong to the above categories)

An illustrative list of Circumstances in which Compliant can be lodged is as under:       
  • Complaints relating to non-receipt of various certificates w.r.t. shares, debentures, bonds
  • Non-receipt of bonus shares, offer for the right shares, notice for call money, share application money, dividend warrant, etc
  •    Non-receipt of interest w.r.t. debentures, bonds and fixed depositsNon- receipt of Redemption amount
  • Non-receipt of payment as per Company Law Board (CLB) order
  • Non-receipt of Pre-matured payments and matured amount of fixed deposits
  • Non-receipt of Annual Report and registration of change in address and other miscellaneous complaints
For details, you can visit http://www.mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/companyformsdownload.html

No fee is prescribed for this form. Further, unlike other forms to be filed on MCA, there is no requirement of having Digital Signature Certificate (DSC). Once the form is filed, an acknowledgment email is sent to the complainant on the email id mentioned in the form

Do you know - anybody can file online complaint against Company?

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) has e-form SCP (Serious complaint eForm). The form was introduced for reporting the serious complaints against a company by filing it on MCA. This is an additional facility to lodge compliant other than handing over a written complaint directly to MCA official in the office of Registrar of Companies.

Who can file a complaint?
  • Shareholder
  • Investor
  • Creditor
  • Employee
  • Deposit holders
  • Others (person who do not belong to above categories)
 Circumstances in which Compliant can be lodged are as under: 
  •  Cessation of Director
  •  Removal of Director
  • Management Dispute
  • Financial Mismanagement
  • Corporate Fraud
  • Accounting Fraud
  • Oppression of Minority Shareholder
  • Others
No fee is prescribed for this form. Further, unlike other forms to be filed on MCA, there is no requirement of having Digital Signature Certificate (DSC).  Once the form is filed, an acknowledgment email is sent to the complainant on the email id mentioned in the form. 

Do you know charge cannot be registered after 120 days?

Highlights on the Companies Amendment (Ordinance), 2018 were circulated by our newsletter dated 5 November 2018. Out of those, one of the significant amendments is related to Charges which is discussed in this article.

Different scenario w.r.t. Creation/Modification of Charges is presented in tables below.

  Charges created/ modified Before 2 November, 2018

Sr. No.
Particulars
Fees
       1.       
Registration of charges within 30 days of such creation or modification
Normal Fees
       2.       
Registration of charges after 30 days but within 300 (30+270) days of such creation or modification
Normal Fees + additional Fees
       3.       
Registration of charges after 300 days of such creation or modification – to be registered within 6 months from 2 November, 2018
Normal Fees + additional Fees

Charges created/ modified after 2 November, 2018

Sr. No.
Particulars
Fees
        1.       
Registration of charges within 30 days of such creation or modification
Normal Fees
        2.       
Registration of charges after 30 days but within 60 (30+30) days of such creation or modification
Normal Fees + additional Fees
        3.       
Registration of charges after 60 days of such creation or modification but within 120 days such creation or modification
Normal Fees + additional Fees + Ad valorem fees
        4.       
Charge cannot be registered after 120 days*


* Omission/Mis-statement in the Charge created or modified can be registered after 120 days subject to Condonation of Delay

 Other Key points to be pointed:
ü    Unregistered charges are treated as unsecured
ü  In case of willful  furnish  of  false  or  incorrect  information  or knowingly  suppressing  any  material information liable  to  fraud  and attract action under Section 447



MCA UPDATE - Amendment in LLP Rules, 2009


Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) has taken a step further for ease of doing business. Starting a business in India has been made easier. MCA has re- engineered the process of Incorporation of Limited Liability Partnership. Following are the major changes:

Reservation of Name:
  1. Form RUN-LLP is introduced for reserving name of proposed LLP and for conversion into LLP.
  2. Form RUN-LLP can be re-submitted within 15 days from the date on which it is marked for re-submission

Incorporation of LLP
  1. Application for incorporation of LLP is to be made in Form No. FiLLiP.
  2. Applicants have an option of filing form for reservation of name. Applicant can either proceed with Form RUN-LLP or Form No. FiLLiP. 
  3. Consent to act as Partner or Designated Partner shall be filed in Form FiLLiP
  4. DIN/DPIN of the proposed 2 designated partners can be applied in Form FiLLiP
  5. The 2 resubmissions are allowed for Form FiLLiP  and the period for re-submission of documents shall not exceed 30 days
  6. The certificate of Incorporation of LLP will be issued by CRC in Form 16.

Changes in Rule 18 pertaining to name guidelines for LLP are as follows:

Rule 18(2)(viii) omitted​:​​  Abbreviated name of company based on the name of the promoter will be allowed.

Rule 18(2)(xiv) omitted​: There is no need to show the scope, scale of activity in the name of Company while incorporation and change in name.

Forms:

Form RUN-LLP, Form FiLLiP, Form 5, Form 17, Form 18 forms will be processed by Central Registration Centre for and on behalf of the jurisdictional registrar.

The above amendment will be effective from 2nd October, 2018


MCA Update – Ease in approval of Managerial Remuneration

Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) vide notification dated 12th September, 2018 has made effective few more sections of Companies Amendment Act, 2017. The list of sections is mentioned below:

Sr. No.
Section of the Companies Act, 2017
Section of the Principal Act, 2013
Particulars
1.
66
196
Appointment of Managing Director, Whole-time Director or Manager
2.
67
197
Overall Maximum Managerial Remuneration and Managerial Remuneration in Case of Absence or Inadequacy of Profits
3.
68
198
Calculation of Profits
4.
69
200
Central Government or Company to Fix Limit with Regard to Remuneration
5.
70
201
Forms of, and Procedure in Relation to, Certain Applications


 The key highlights of the amendment are as follows:
  1.  Any person who has completed the age of seventy years can be appointed as Managerial personnel by taking shareholders’ approval in the form of special resolution. However, if where no such special resolution is passed but votes cast in favour of the motion exceed the votes, if any, cast against the motion, the person can be appointed with the approval of Central Government. [Applicable to Private and Public Companies]     
  2. In case of Public Companies,
    1. Approval of Central Government is required for appointment of managerial personnel in case if the conditions specified in Part I of the Schedule V are not complied with.
    2. Approval of Central Government is not required for the payment of remuneration exceeding 11% of the net Profit of the company subject to compliance of schedule V and by passing Special resolution in General Meeting.
    3. Prior approval of following is required before obtaining the approval in the general meeting (for paying remuneration in excess of limits and in case of waiver of remuneration paid in excess of limits as mentioned section 197 read with schedule V)in case if the Company has defaulted in payment of dues from: 
      1. Any Bank
      2. Public Financial institutions     
      3. Non-Convertible Debentures holders
      4. Other secured creditors
  3. The Auditor has to make statement in his audit report about the compliance of section 197 and schedule V
  4.  4. All the applications which are pending with that Central Government shall stand abate, and the Companies shall obtain the approval in accordance with the revised provisions within a period of one year.
Further, to give effect to this notification, MCA has also amended the Companies (Appointment and Remuneration of Managerial Personnel) Rules, 2014 and schedule V. 

Disclaimer:   The article is not intended to replace appropriate professional advice required before acting on any matter. MMJC assumes no responsibility in respect of anything done or omitted to be done by person in reliance on the contents of this article.